Contact Us

Bishop Smith decries lack of debate over CFR bill

By Sarah Mac Donald - 04 May, 2015

Bishop Michael Smith of Meath.

Bishop Michael Smith of Meath.

The Bishop of Meath has said it is regrettable that the Children and Family Relationships Bill was adopted by the Dáil without any substantial debate.

In a statement on Sunday outlining his concerns about the proposal before the people of Ireland on 22 May, Bishop Michael Smith said changing a major article of the Constitution merits detailed consideration since unforeseen consequences can arise.

He said the family is described by the Constitution ‘as the natural, primary and fundamental unit group of society’.

Underlining that marriage and family life have served society well for thousands of years, providing a committed relationship between a man and a woman for the upbringing and care of their children, Dr Smith said to change the meaning of marriage would seem “an extraordinary rejection of what is good for society”.

Elsewhere in his statement, the bishop said he did not think that there is “anything offensive in believing, as we have always done, that marriage is a permanent union between a man and a woman”.

He added that the search for equality in our society will not be advanced by undermining the very cornerstone on which a just and stable society is built.

As a group, the bishops have already issued a statement, ‘Marriage is important – reflect before you change it’.

Bishop Smith said the hierarchy respected the views of people who think differently to them, “trusting that our sincerely held views will also be heard and respected”.

He also highlighted that homosexuals living in Ireland have “undoubtedly suffered discrimination over the years” and he very much welcomed the measures adopted in recent years to address this injustice.

“In this regard also, the values of the Gospel make compellingly clear to us the dignity of every human person, and that all must be treated equally and with respect,” he said.

He said the specific proposal to amend the Constitution is about the people’s understanding of marriage and family life.

“I accept that addressing inequality is undeniably an obligation on society. My particular and deep-rooted concern, however, is that the current proposal introduces a profound change into our understanding of marriage, of the family and of parenthood.”

“The proposal, taken together with the provisions of the Children and Family Relationships Bill, removes the mention of ‘mother’ and ‘father’ from a whole range of existing legislation. Denying children the right to a mother and a father is not, I believe, an appropriate way to address the question of inequality in our society.”

The bishop said that though the current debate is often presented as a clash between Church and State, people must avoid seeing this issue in this very blinkered manner.

He underlined that the Church’s beliefs around the Sacrament of Marriage are not at issue and will not change regardless of the outcome of the Referendum.

“The Constitution, first and foremost, serves the whole of society and the common good. The people are being asked to put aside the understanding of marriage and family life that pre-dates both Church and State.”

Referring to recent comments by Government ministers and others supporting the proposal he said they suggested that they no longer believe that there is a special value in a child having the love of a mother and a father, or that men and women bring something distinct or unique to the lives of their children.

“They seem to believe that gender does not matter,” he said.

These comments, Bishop Smith stated, “affirm the view that when you redefine marriage, you redefine the family and you redefine the very meaning of parenthood”.

Underlining that the Constitution belongs to the people of the Nation, he said the choice we are asked to make in the Marriage Referendum on 22 May is a decision that only the people can make. “It rests neither with politicians nor bishops.”

“All of us, therefore, need to reflect carefully; we need to inform ourselves on the central issues before deciding how we will vote.”

 Follow us on Twitter @CINetNews

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,