By Susan Gately - 11 April, 2018
“In our two communities or in our various communities we are happy enough the way we are and we couldn’t be bothered,” says Bishop Alan McGuckian SJ of Raphoe.
A bishop from Northern Ireland has blamed the current political stalemate in Northern Ireland on indifference. Bishop Alan McGuckian SJ, originally from Antrim, made his comments just before a series of events marked the 20th anniversary of the signing of the Good Friday Agreement yesterday.
“The reason why we are still stuck in Northern Ireland is that in our two communities or in our various communities we are happy enough the way we are and we couldn’t be bothered,” Bishop Alan McGuckian SJ told CatholicIreland.
In an interview after he celebrated a Mass at Stranmillis College, Belfast at the weekend, where he preached on St Thomas’s famous words, “Unless I see the holes the nails made and I can put my finger into them … I refuse to believe”, Bishop McGuckian said the impasse in Northern politics was due to the indifference of Christians. “If our politicians are not leading us to really make peace and reconciliation work, it is because we are not demanding them to lead us. They are responding to us and that is a terrible wound that we don’t even recognise because we are happy enough with it.”
In Northern Ireland we are aware of the terrible wounds that live on in so many people’s hearts because of what they have suffered and continue to suffer as a result of the Troubles, said the Bishop of Raphoe, “but there’s another wound in us, a wound on the face of the Church, of us Christians” – and that wound is indifference.
“I have to see my indifference about this terribly serious issue as a wound. We have to experience that our indifference is a scandal. If it pained us then as believers we’d be able to touch the wound because it’s a wound on the body of Christ, and that would be our way to new life, but we have to face up to it.” Otherwise, he said, we are just “sleepwalking”. He added: “I don’t know where it will lead but it is not good.”
Bishop McGuckian joined 170 Christians from several denominations, including Church of Ireland Bishop Trevor Williams, at the all-Ireland Focolare weekend on ‘Building Community Together’. Former BBC security correspondent Brian Rowan, author of Unfinished Peace, gave the keynote address on Saturday.
Asked by CatholicIreland if there was any possibility of the collapse of the Good Friday agreement and a return to violence, Mr Rowan said he believed the war was over. “I am pretty convinced about that.” The dissident organisations that emerged just before the Good Friday agreement in 1998 had not been able to “recreate the conflict” because there was not “the community support or community tolerance, not the wherewithal that would allow such a repeat of the conflict period”.
He considered whether that meant we are not in danger of someone being killed tomorrow or the next day, answering that we haven’t got to that point.
“I think the next phase of our politics is going to be a kind of tug-of-war between union and unity and here we are arriving at the Good Friday anniversary and the political institutions that are at the heart of it are no longer there. And we are in danger of them not being restored,” he said.
Given how the huge hurdles of the ceasefire and arms decommissioning were overcome, Mr Rowan said if issues like the Irish language, marriage equality and a Bill of Rights could not be resolved, we don’t deserve a Stormont.
“So when these international visitors come to us, [on the anniversary of the Good Friday agreement] they would give everything they have for what we’ve got,” he said. “It may be a 50-year process but we are 20 years down the road and they are at a beginning. So there is some learning we can give them. But I do believe the war is over and the next bit should not be that difficult.”